THC’s Top 50 Transport Sims

PC Gamer can keep their tarot cards, Rock, Paper, Shotgun their tea leaves, and Eurogamer their roadkill entrails. Here on the Corner we rank games using the most scientific/democratic method available. In the past your votes have established beyond a shadow of a doubt the finest combat sims and PC wargames around. Over the next week or two, if you’re willing, I’m hoping we can compile a list of the very best transport sims.

For the purposes of this popularity contest, a transport sim is any predominantly peaceable game with first-person vehicle control or first-person vehicle views at its nexus. The vehicles in question must be contemporary or historical and their primary purpose shouldn’t be motorsport (race sims will get their own THC Top 25 at some point).

Everyone has six votes at their disposal. List your three favourite titles in order of preference and I’ll award half of your votes to the game in the no.1 position, two to the second place one, and the remaining vote to your third choice.

Wax lyrical about your choices and your waxy words may well find their way into the table. As there are sure to be titles on the list that I’ve never played, I’d much prefer to use a quote from a true fan than rely on something desiccated or vague that I’ve concocted myself.

To prevent sprawl, I’ve grouped some closely-related games into single entries. Please vote for three unrelated titles rather than plucking your selection from one or two of these amalgamated entries. Passion for, say, SCS Software’s marvels should be communicated by awarding ETS2 or ATS your top slot, not filling your entire list with made-in-CZ trucking sims.

Just because you don’t see a favourite in the table, that doesn’t mean you can’t vote for it. At launch twenty games are on the ballot paper, but I wouldn’t be surprised if the list doubled in size in the weeks to come.

Games can be sorted alphabetically and by popularity. While the table seems to display fine on a standard PC monitor, you may have problems viewing it on a phone or tablet. Sorry about that.

GAME

VOTES

Aerofly FS

(AFS2) "Though not quite as fleet as the original, the follow-up is still fast enough to make Microsoft Flight Simulator feel sluggish and needy. Overflying downtown San Francisco in the default FSX Learjet I'm lucky to see 40 frames a second. Doing the same thing in AFS2, my modest GPU delivers prettier vistas and a more striking bizjet at a sizzling 70 FPS." (Tim)

0

BVE and OpenBVE

(BVE) "It may take a reasonable understanding of Japanese to get some of the better routes up and running, but once you’re rolling this train sim feels more involving to drive than any other (Though I will throw a shout out to Run8). Doesn’t always look pretty, but it’s about the drive." (Shrapnel1977)

2

BeamNG.drive

"BeamNG does its beguiling with Rigs of Rods-reminiscent soft-body physics, amazing damage modelling, and admirable modability." (Tim)

(link)

0

City Car Driving

"The heart of the sim, 'free driving' is where the real magic happens. Cruising around Ersatz Russian City #1 there are moments, usually when light levels are low or snowflakes are whirling against your windscreen, when reality and unreality begin to smudge. Suddenly you're no longer sitting in that lumbar-supporting office chair in the back bedroom at 27 Cavalier Approach pretending to guide an elderly Lada Niva through tangled traffic streams in a bustling foreign city. You're actually guiding an elderly Lada Niva through tangled traffic streams in a bustling foreign city." (Tim)

0

Condor I & II

“The follow-up to what's generally regarded as the PC's most realistic glider sim, recreates ridge and sail lift subtleties much better than its predecessor and the climate code is now clever enough to conjure up 'blue' thermals (thermals sans white fluffy hats) and cloud streets.” (Tim)

0

Derail Valley

"After my first ascent attempt ends in failure, I roll back into the yard and try again with a longer, more vigorous run-up. This time the sander does the business, the temp needle stays out of the red zone, and momentum is maintained. I reach the summit with sweat beads on my brow, a satisfied smile on my face, and a thought circling my cranium like a bottled bluebottle. "When was the last time Train Sim World worked me this hard?" (Tim)

0

Diesel Railcar Simulator

"A lot of product at a modest price." (rochrist)


"One of the sim’s strengths is the way its three default sceneries call to mind the dense, diverse British rail network without slavishly replicating portions of it. Wise Lapioware understand that nowhere can be everywhere." (Tim)

1

Farming Simulator

"I can't pretend that I wouldn't like to see the devs take a leaf chapter out of MR Software's or Kunos Simulazioni's vehicle modelling book and beef-up realism in future instalments, but I also can't pretend that the money-manured plough-plant-harvest cycle at the heart of the game isn't one of the most natural and compelling campaign mechanisms I've ever encountered." (Tim)

1

Kerbal Space Program

"It takes sixty-five thousand errors before you are qualified to make a rocket." (Wernher von Braun)

2

Microsoft Flight Simulator (FS2004 and FSX)

"More hobby than game, Flight Simulator can be enjoyed in countless different ways. It welcomes nostalgics, explorers, aspirants and obsessives. It caters for the sociable, the solitary, the stressed and the war weary. It soothes, it trains, it entertains and employs. One moment it's effortlessly satisfying our wanderlust and reminding us that borders only exist on maps and in minds, the next it's binding us closer to the places we call home. To pigeon-hole MSFS is to malign it." (Tim)


(FS9) "A couple of years post-9/11 I was on the brink of giving up on my stalled flying career (no pun intended). I picked up FS9 to brush up on my instrument skills. A few months later, employed as a flight instructor I discovered PMDG’s 737 add-on. I flew it constantly just for fun, and the experience eventually helped land me (pun intended) at a major US airline. Massive career help aside, FS9 to this date is the one I had the most fun in and spent the most time with." (Jer Stryker)

3

Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020

"What it lacks in physics is makes up for in just about everything else imaginable." (Shrapnel1977)


"A true experience revolution, it will be the benchmark for flight sims (all sims?) for years." (hellfighter6)


"I’ve hovered over the 1914 invasion corridors of the Austro-Hungarian army, travelled from Assab to Aden along the same coast as the Regia Aeronautica pilots did in WW2, and traced my own path from Cape Town to Cairo through a dozen countries, and noticed every mountain range, every desert, and every little town along the way. No other game makes the world feel so big and yet so small." (Oneknown)

17

Narrowboat Simulator

"Right now the graphics are cruder than Chaucer's miller, things like ripples and reflections, ducks and dragonflies being wholly dependent on the power of your CPU (Cranial Photoshopping Unit). You put up with the barren towpaths and cruciform trees because Michael's love for and interest in narrowboating declares itself every time you push the tiller or slide your craft into a lock's dank canyon." (Tim)

0

OMSI

"OMSI's fleet of '80s doubledeckers have an extraordinarily broad vocabulary of squeaks and whines, growls and hums. Their music morphs with every pedal press and road surface change. To drive them is to unlock a lifetime of public transport memories... school buses, night buses, London buses... close your eyes and you can almost smell the diesel, feel the vibrating window-glass cold against your cheek. In plainer terms, Marcel Kuhnt und Rüdiger Hülsmann have created some of simulation's most charismatic and evocative vehicles." (Tim)

2

Prepar3D

“The fact the number of home-schooled student pilots around the world began increasing dramatically at roughly the same time Lockheed Martin started selling $60 'academic licences' for FSXI-in-all-but-name P3D, may or may not be coincidental.” (Tim)

0

Reentry

"The criminally underrated, button-accurate simulation of Mercury, Gemini, and Apollo, and you can play in VR to boot? The “DCS of space flight simulation”. How could this not be number 1 in anyone’s book? The fact that this game doesn’t have universal name recognition in the sim community is downright criminal." (CaptainKoloth)


"No other game captures the feeling of terror that washes over you when every light in your little tin can shuts off at once and you’re left with a flashlight frantically skimming your manual for the right emergency restart procedure." (Oneknown)

6

SCS Software's Truck Simulators

"Euro Truck Simulator 2 at night, driving towards the full moon, a truckers’ radio channel at low volume, 400 miles to your destination and open roads to get there? Some of the most zen gaming possible." (cederic)


"American Truck Simulator in VR is amazing" (VFRHawk)

9

Sail Simulator

"If you simply want to mess about in verisimilar virtual boats… to feel the spray in your face, and impatient wind-spurred wood, fibreglass or carbon-fibre beneath your feet or backside, this is the sailing sim for you." (Tim)

0

SimCopter

"A dynamic procedural world, the freedom to set your own goals, and a game easy enough to learn to be accessible." (Oneknown)

3

Spintires, MudRunner, & SnowRunner

(Spintires) "A cross-country trucking sim with sludge so real you'll be digging it out from under your fingernails for weeks." (Tim)

4

Take On Helicopters

"Combining flight sim, adventure and a little dash of business, it's the most refreshing flying game I've played in years. I may, courtesy of an FSX or Search & Rescue 4 sortie, have delivered SWAT teams, skycraned cargo, and medevaced accident casualties before, but I'm pretty sure I've never combined aviation with flirtation or interrogation, or spent inter-mission intermissions in a 3D hangar overseeing helo upgrades, repaints and repairs." (Tim)

0

Train Simulator

"Couple Train Simulator to high quality routes and rolling stock and the results can be mesmerising... Still the first choice for any train simmer fascinated by steam locos." (Tim)

0

Train/Transport Fever series

"Natty first-person cab views allow Urban Games' transport management sims to sneak into this hit parade." (Tim)

3

Vehicle Simulator

"Don't expect the realism or polish of an MSFS or X-Plane. Do expect intuitive mouse steering, luscious sunsets, and plenty of atmosphere." (Tim)

0

X-Plane

"XP11 is my current go-to for learning a complex airliner. It’s very fiddly to make look pretty, and as the airliners start showing up for MSFS I may end up leaving XP behind, but we’re not there yet." (Jer Stryker)


"When training for real world flying lessons the physics in X-Plane cannot be matched. Pick up some decent mesh and scenery and it feels like the purest flight sim there is, hopefully XP12 will bring more convincing weather." (Shrapnel1977)

3

13 Comments

  1. 1 – SCS Software’s Truck Simulators

    Euro Truck Simulator 2 at night, driving towards the full moon, a truckers’ radio channel at low volume, 400 miles to your destination and open roads to get there? Some of the most zen gaming possible.

    American Truck Simulator doesn’t quite achieve that same depth of relaxation but easily compensates with its more diverse landscapes. Driving through Utah thinking, “That looks familiar” and finding photos from one my trips to the US that I could almost replicate exactly in-game..

    — no more on my list.

    Turns out I just don’t play transport sims. It was tempting to suggest GTA V due to the vast variety of vehicles available (and the ability to do firefighter missions in its fire trucks) but it’s just too arcade and not something I’d recommend to people.

    Attach ranged weapons to the transport and it’s a whole different story. I have a vast list of recommendations for the eventual racing list too.

    But even though I own several of the entries in Tim’s initial list, just that one that matters to me.

    [votes tabulated]

  2. 1 – MSFS by Asobo. A true experience revolution, it will be the benchmark for flight sims (all sims?) for years.

    2 – Spintires/Mudrunner/Snowrunner. That mud tho.

    3 – X-Plane. You can get it looking close to MSFS as long as you invest hundreds of dollars of custom scenery and terabytes of ortho image. “gRapHicS aRen’T eVerYthinG” — no, which is why X-Plane gets a vote.

    [votes tabulated]

  3. 1- Reentry. The criminally underrated, button-accurate simulation of Mercury, Gemini, and Apollo, and you can play in VR to boot? The “DCS of space flight simulation”. How could this not be number 1 in anyone’s book? The fact that this game doesn’t have universal name recognition in the sim community is downright criminal.

    [votes tabulated]

  4. 1. MSFS 2020 – What it lacks in physics is makes up for in just about everything else imaginable.

    2. BVE Trainsim – It may take a reasonable understanding of Japanese to get some of the better routes up and running, but once you’re rolling this train sim feels more involving to drive than any other (Though I will throw a shout out to Run8). Doesn’t always look pretty, but it’s about the drive.

    3. XPlane – When training for real world flying lessons the physics in XPlane cannot be matched, Pick up some decent mesh and scenery and it feels like the purist flight sim there is, hopefully XP12 will bring more convincing weather.

    Only three votes is tough here. It was impossible for me not to vote for two flight sims given the sheer amount of time I’ve spent in both (and FSX before them).

    I have a deep soft spot for “OMSI”, a tremendous respect for “ETS2”, a longstanding love/hate thing with “Dovetail Train Simulator” (not TSW), a delight for the charms of “Jalopy”, and an unfeasible adoration for “Densha De Go: Final” (On PC of course, not PS2). If only I could vote for them all.

    [votes tabulated]

  5. 1) MSFS – just getting back in to it with the Fenix A320, GSX and Pro ATC/SR. Stunning. Totally replaced P3D despite how much I’ve spent on addons for that

    2) SCS Truck Sims. Quite enjoyed ETS II, but ATS in VR is amazing.

    3) Farming Sim. For when you just want to relax and move slooooooowly.

    [votes tabulated]

  6. If I could put all civilian flight sims throughout time as one vote I would, but which one (or ones) to vote for? SubLogic’s Flight Simulator II? On our Atari 800 PC it was the first flight sim I ever played, but I was pretty small. Microsoft Flight Simulator 4.0? At 12 years old I would fly the Learjet across the country in real time with one shade of blue for the sky, and one shade of red for the ground and almost no scenery, while I had my little brother and sister sit behind me as my passengers. Asobo’s new MSFS? I believe it will be the definitive all-around sim of my choice, but I have been unable to spend much time with it yet. So I think. . .

    1. Microsoft Flight Simulator 2004: A Century of Flight (FS9) – A couple years post-9/11 I was on the brink of giving up on my stalled flying career (no pun intended). I picked up FS9 to brush up on my instrument skills. A few months later, employed as a flight instructor I discovered PMDG’s 737 add-on. I flew it constantly just for fun, and the experience eventually helped land me (pun intended) at a major US airline. Massive career help aside, FS9 to this date is the one I had the most fun in and spent the most time with. The collector’s tin sits proudly on a shelf next to my professional logbook and models of different airliners I have piloted in my career.

    2. Euro Truck Simulator 2 – After flying all day, this is my relaxation game. Using the “Local Radio” mod I cruise around Europe, looking out the window and enjoying the views and the local music and news. I usually don’t understand the language, but it makes it feel more like I’m there.

    3. X-Plane 11 – Because I don’t play enough transport sims I have to put another flight sim here. If I want the fun of operating a classic 747-200 or Concorde, or if I need to practice on a modern Airbus widebody for work, XP11 is my current go-to for learning a complex airliner. It’s very fiddly to make look pretty, and as the airliners start showing up for MSFS I may end up leaving XP behind, but we’re not there yet.

    [votes tabulated]

  7. 1. Reentry – No other game captures the feeling of terror that washes over you when every light in your little tin can shuts off at once and you’re left with a flashlight frantically skimming your manual for the right emergency restart procedure.

    2. Flight Simulator 2020 – I’ve hovered over the 1914 invasion corridors of the Austro-Hungarian army, travelled from Assab to Aden along the same coast as the Regia Aeronautica pilots did in WW2, and traced my own path from Cape Town to Cairo through a dozen countries, and noticed every mountain range, every desert, and every little town along the way. No other game makes the world feel so big and yet so small.

    3. Sim Copter – A dynamic procedural world, the freedom to set your own goals, and a game easy enough to learn to be accessible.

    Also, I don’t think they qualify here, but I loved the driving sim parts of Mafia I and LA Noire. I don’t think there are other games that capture the experience of driving around a city in the 1920s or 1940s, and I want more of them.

    [votes tabulated]

  8. MSFS 2020: The bugs are mostly gone through the steady diet of updates, incredible free content continues to be added on a regular basis and the hardware demands are no where near as severe as they were at launch. The gold standard going forward.

    American Truck Simulator can’t wait for them to come east of the Mississippi

    Diesel Railcar Simulator: A lot of product at a modest price

    Kerbal Space Program

    Train Sim World: bugs and all does ALL the THINGs I wanted from a train sim.

    [votes tabulated]

  9. 1) MSFS20 – think this is going to be the standout winner due to scope and beauty.

    2) OMSI – I just adored reading Tim’s accounts of this game on FP, it’s just so whimsical.

    3) Spin-tires- going in the other direction entirely for “action” in your transport sim…

    I don’t play a lot of transport sims so have gone with some fairly derivative picks 🙂

    Thanks for the little gift that came with the mug Tim they are excellent and got the Mrs’ seal of approval!

    [votes tabulated]

  10. Not sure if it really meets the genre criteria. First title that comes to my mind is

    1) Transport Tycoon (1994) – no first person view though
    2) Train Fever, Transport Fever, Transport Fever 2 series
    3) Kerbal Space Program

    If my first entry is not eligible please add MudRunner on 3rd

    [votes tabulated]

  11. Maybe Top 50 is a little too optimistic, haha. From this I’ve learned that I’m not the only one who plays civilian transport sims few and far between. Still, I enjoy reading about them, endeavor to play them, and value the recommendations from others. I’ve had Reentry on my Steam wish list for a while. Maybe it’s time to get it. On the other hand, I’ve been stuck in the snow/mud enough where I live to know that I have absolutely no interest in a “stuck in the snow/mud” simulator, no matter how popular it might be!

  12. 1. Diesel Railcar Simulator

    2. MSFS2020

    3. BVE Trainsim

    PS: There are a few missing like OpenRails, Ship Simulator, and others, like Fernbus, Tourist Bus Simulator, Bus Simulator, etc.

Leave a Reply